Getting to know you,
Since the Big Ten is the oldest conference in the nation it seems natural, because of their highly competitive nature and the border line existence of these states, that rivalries have been formed over the years and continue being formed even in the 21 Century. Some of these rivalries exist because they offer bragging rights within that state. The history and the formation of these rivalries are both interesting and in most cases very amusing.
BIG TEN RIVALRIES
Wisconsin and Minnesota and the Paul Bunyan Axe. The most notable of rivalries and the longest running rivalry is the annual football game between the Wisconsin Badgers and the Minnesota Golden Gophers with the winner picking up the Paul Bunyan Axe. The first game in this series was in 1890 with the Gophers winning 63-0.
This score along with the other 119 scores are marked on the handle in red ink. There have been so many games that the scores scroll up and down the width of the handle on both sides. Now it is necessary to mark the scores on the narrow edges of the six-foot handle.
The Axe is on the side of the field of the team winning the previous year. At the conclusion of the game, the winning team, all of them, grab the Axe and parade it around the stadium.
Actually there wasn’t a Paul Bunyan Axe in existence until much later in the 1940’s. In 1906 the game was canceled by President Theodore Roosevelt who decided that the heated college rivalry should take a year off and “cool it’.
Dr. R.B. Fouch of Minneapolis fashioned a log of black walnut into a traveling trophy the he hoped would compare to the well-known “Little Brown Jug “ of the Minnesota and Michigan matches. This first trophy was christened as the “Slab of Bacon” with the idea that the winning team would “bring home the bacon”.
But later on in the mid 40”s, the trophy became the “Missing Slab of Bacon”. Following a Wisconsin home game win the students and fans ran crazy over the field and the trophy disappeared. and remained loss. Meanwhile the teams had to play for something so in 1948 the Wisconsin W Club instituted the “Paul Bunyan’s Axe”, which they deemed more fitting for this great rivalry.
In 1994, the Slab of Bacon was back in the news when the long-lost trophy was found after a Camp Randall Stadium storage room was cleaned out. Wisconsin officials estimated that it had been missing since 1945; yet the scores of every Wisconsin-Minnesota game from 1930-70 were printed on the back of the slab. It is one of those Twilight Zonesque mysteries that remains unexplained, and contributes to the legend of Minnesota’s and Wisconsin’s “Border Battle” rivalry.
Wisconsin and Iowa and the Heartland Bul. This is another long term rivalry, but it was not put into trophy form until 2004. This series is also over 100 years old but with the expansion of the conference, these two teams are now in different divisions and this brings this annual clash to a halt. (Similar to what happened between Oklahoma and Nebraska)
The trophy for this event was a brass bull, a symbol of the farming background of these two schools. The Heartland trophy was designed and crafted by former University of Iowa football player, Frank Strub. The Trophy is 30 inches tall, 36 inches long and 18 inches deepand is mounted on a walnut base. This Trophy became the 16th traveling trophy in the Big Ten.
Iowa and Minnesota and Floyd the Pig. The history of this traveling trophy starts with the game in 1934 and the rough treatment given Ozzie Simmons, a black Iowa running back, by the Gophers. Enough said.
The following year, the Gophers were 5-0 and the Hawkeye’s were 4-0-1 and that game was to be played in Iowa City. Fevers were still running high and the Gophers coach requested police protection and was granted coverage. In return the Iowa Governor said, “if the officials stand for any rough tactics like Minnesota used last year, I’m sure the crowd won’t,” clearly a threat. And then, as you can imagine, the remarks and letters and phone calls flowed between the two State Houses.
To lighten the mood, Minnesota Governor Floyd Olson sent a telegram to Governor Herring which read, “Minnesota folks are excited about your statement about the Iowa crowd lynching the Minnesota football team. I have assured them that your are a law abiding gentleman only trying to get our goat…I will bet you a Minnesota prize hog against an Iowa prize hog that Minnesota wins.”
The Gophers won 13-6 and Iowa’s star, Ozzie Simmons, played an injury-free game. Gopher players went out of their way to compliment Simmons and Simmons praised the Gophers for their clean, hard-fought play.
The Iowa Governor was given an award winning prize pig by the Rosedale Farms in Iowa and the pig was named Floyd of Rosedale, after the Minnesota Governor and a few day later Governor Herring personally walked Floyd of Rosedale into the office of Minnesota Governor Floyd Olson.
Now you might think all was now hunky dory and every thing w
as cool, but other people got into this ongoing story.
Iowa social crusader Virgil Case swore out a criminal warrant in Des Moines against Governor Herring, alleging that the bet violated Iowa gambling laws. Herring jokingly stated that he had retained Governor Olson as his attorney, who argued that it was not a true bet because Herring did not have a chance of winning it. However, an assistant Iowa attorney general convinced a judge to dismiss on jurisdictional grounds because the bet had been made in Minnesota and Iowa City, beyond the local court’s jurisdiction. Crusader Case also argued that the governors were guilty of violating federal gambling laws because the pig had been placed into interstate commerce when Herring made good on the bet, but the U.S. Attorneys declined to prosecute. President Franklin Roosevelt’s former son-in-law, Curtis Dall, who attended the 1935 game as a guest of the governors, suggested that they name the pig “New Deal.” Herring vetoed that proposal.
Since the two schools could not continue wagering a live pig, Governor Olson commissioned a Saint Paul sculptor Charles Brioscho to capture Floyd’s image. The result was a Bronze pig trophy 21 inches long and 15 inches high. And this has been the trophy every since.
Minnesota and Michigan and the Little Brown Jug. This rivalry started on very friendly and fun terms.
In 1901 Fielding Yost took over the head coach position for the Wolverines and the team took off with a win streak of 28 wins and in 1903 were scheduled to meet the Gophers who also were fielding one of the best teams in school history. Being a home game the Minnesota fans were hyped up for this great showdown between these two giants and the possibility of ending the Michigan streak.
Yost was worried that the high Gopher fans might try to contaminate his water so he sent a student manager to buy something that they could keep water in for the players. For thirty cents the manager came back with a five-gallon jug.
Twenty thousand fans watched the match up between the two teams in an overflowing of the Northrop Field. Minnesota held the fabled “point-a-minute” squad to just one touchdown but hadn’t yet managed to score a touchdown of their own. Finally, late in the second half, the Gophers reached the end zone to tie the game at 6–6. As clouds from an impending storm hung overhead, pandemonium struck when Minnesota fans stormed the field in celebration. Eventually the game had to be called with two minutes remaining. The Wolverines walked off the field, leaving the jug behind in the locker room.
The next day custodian Oscar Munson found the jug and gave it to L. J. Cooke, the Atheletic Director for Minnesota and told him “Yost left his jug”. Being all excited to have this little bit of memorabilia, they painted it brown and on the side wrote, “Michigan Jug – Captured by Oscar, October 31, 1903” and on the side along with the score “Michigan 6, Minnesota 6”. And of course in the spirit of favored owners they wrote the Minnesota score much larger than the Michigan score.
A couple of days later the Michigan coach sent a letter to AD Cooke and told him he had left the jug and wanted it back. I can imagine the grin on AD Cooke’s face as he wrote back, “Yes, we have your little brown jug and if you want it back you have to win it.”
Another traveling trophy was launched in the Big Ten.
Roger
The Red Clad Coot in the Desert

